Residents stayed in Ghana because they felt they could make it there economically, were supported by educational opportunities
Ghanaian Obstetrics and Gynecology residents say in-country training programs contributed to their decision to remain in their home country to practice medicine, new University of Michigan research shows.
The retention of trained health care providers in developing countries is a key component to improving health and achieving the United Nations Millennium Development Goals, which aim to decrease maternal and child mortality. But the migration of health workers from developing to developed countries has resulted in a health care workforce crisis that continues to threaten progress in global health.
U-M research to be published today in the journal Academic Medicine shows that the in-country program is one of three factors that contribute strongly to OB/GYN residents not migrating out of country to practice medicine.
"The most important factor is that there is a program in place for medical students to enter when they finish so they don't have to leave the country for obstetrics and gynecology training," says Frank Anderson, M.D., MPH, associate professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at U-M, and a lead author in the study.
The U-M Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology has been working with the two major academic medical centers in Ghana for over 20 years - Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital (Accra, Ghana) and Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (Kumasi, Ghana). The program has played an ongoing role in supporting OBGYN training in Ghana.
"Partnerships between academic health centers in developed and developing countries provide opportunities to address the global health care crisis in a significant and sustainable way," Anderson says, adding that such programs have longevity that other efforts cant match.
Brain drain is a well-documented problem. According to the Ghana Ministry of Health, approximately 60 percent of physicians trained in Ghana in the 1980s left the country. As of 2002, 30 percent of physicians trained in Ghana were practicing in the United States or Canada. In 2003, the United Kingdom approved 850 work permits for Ghanaian health and medical personnel, including physicians and nurses.
The new U-M study took place in July 2006 and consisted of a survey of 20 residents and interviews with a smaller group of nine residents at the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital in Accra, one of U-Ms partner universities in Ghana. It looked at factors that affected physician retention including having an in-country training program, social factors and the economy.
"Economic factors tend to push people out of Ghana," Anderson says, adding that social factors serve as a strong counterpoint. "Ghanaians love Ghana. People love their countries and if they have opportunity to stay, they'll stay. Its not our role as an academic institution to contribute to brain drain."
Most respondents (95 percent) said they would have left Ghana if postgraduate training had not been available, (80 percent) reported that becoming an OB/GYN specialty was important to them, (75 percent) indicated that the program trained them to practice in Ghana, and (85 percent) were certain they would stay in Ghana after completing the program.
Previous studies have shown that in-country residency programs help retain physicians. A previous study of certified specialists who had completed an academic university-based postgraduate training program in Obstetrics and Gynecology at both the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital (Accra, Ghana) and the Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (Kumasi, Ghana), showed that 29 out of 30 residents stayed in the country.
According to those studies, high retention was due to the availability and presence of a viable training program in Ghana while social and economic factors also played a significant role in graduates decisions to stay in Ghana, Anderson says.
Interest in OB/GYN among Ghanaian residents is high. Given that obtaining OB/GYN training in the U.S. is highly competitive for foreign-trained doctors, the postgraduate training program in Ghana gives residents a viable option for this specialized training.
The implications of this study are great, Anderson says. The Michigan model has shown that centers with established and well-functioning educational systems in long-term partnerships with academic health centers in developing countries can help create high-quality and sustainable training programs. These in-country programs enhance the long-term effort to increase the number of health workers globally and reduce maternal mortality.
In addition to Anderson, co-authors are Yvette Clinton, Ph.D., and E. Yao Kwawukume, MB ChB, FWACs
Funding/Support: Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Michigan
Other disclosures: None
Ethical approval: The University of Michigan Institutional Review Board and the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital Ethics Review Committee approved this study.
Previous presentations: Portions of the data from this manuscript have been presented at the University of Michigan Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology Grand Rounds, March 11, 2010.
Journal ref: Acad Med. 2010;85:1564-1570. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181f09112
Note: The University of Michigan's work in Ghana will be the subject of a symposium that is part of the 50th anniversary Peace Corps campus-wide celebration from 1:30 to 5 p.m., Thursday, Oct. 14, 2010 in the Pendleton Room at the Michigan Union. For more information, visit http://peacecorps.umich.edu/events.html.
Learn about the U-M's long history and exciting future in Ghana and how both Ghana and U-M have benefited from partnerships in a number of fields including medicine, engineering, technology and museum studies. This symposium, which will be complemented by a performance featuring specially commissioned Ghanaian Fontomfrom drums played by visiting Ghanaian drummers and percussion students of the University of Michigan School of Music, Theatre & Dance, is sponsored by the Medical School. Speakers include: Dr. Timothy Johnson, Medical School; Dr. Lisa Newman, Medical School; Dr. Cary Engleberg, Medical School; Prof. Kathleen Sienko, Engineering; and Prof. Ray Silverman, Museum Studies.
Written by Margarita B. Wagerson